- November 12, 2026
An Ormond Beach woman employed as an exceptional student education teacher at Old Kings Elementary School has been arrested for possession of a controlled substance without a prescription following a Flagler County Sheriff’s Office investigation into the alleged theft of prescription medication from a coworker.
According to the Flagler County Sheriff’s Office, a school resource deputy was contacted on Oct. 5 after a school employee reported having video evidence showing a coworker, Deborah Gibbens, 51, of Ormond Beach, taking her prescribed hydrocodone from her office.
The employee told deputies she had noticed several pills missing from her prescription, which she kept in a backpack in her office, approximately three weeks earlier. She then set up a surveillance camera in the office.
On the day the theft was reported, the employee returned from a meeting and discovered that two of her four remaining pills were missing. Investigators said surveillance footage showed Gibbens searching through the backpack, removing the pill container, putting it back and zipping up the backpack.
The employee told deputies she did not know how Gibbens knew the medication was in her backpack and had not given her permission to take any pills.
According to the Sheriff's Office, Gibbens initially denied entering the backpack or taking the medication when questioned by a deputy. After being informed that the incident had been captured on camera, she admitted to taking pills on multiple occasions, beginning Aug. 31.
Gibbens told investigators she believed the pills were ibuprofen and Tylenol. Deputies said she did not have a prescription for hydrocodone. The employee chose not to pursue theft charges.
On Oct. 6, deputies obtained an arrest warrant for Gibbens on a charge of possession of a controlled substance without a prescription. Later that day, the FCSO Fugitive Apprehension Unit assisted the Ormond Beach Police Department in locating and arresting her.
“Teachers are trusted to set the example as they should be role models for their students. Sneaking into a coworker’s backpack, stealing medicine she didn’t have a prescription for, then lying about it severely breaks that trust,” Sheriff Rick Staly said. “It’s clear she has a problem. I hope she gets the help she needs.”
Flagler Schools Superintendent LaShakia Moore also addressed the arrest.
“Flagler Schools remains deeply proud of and confident in our extraordinary faculty and staff who serve our students with dedication and care every day. One individual’s poor choice is in no way a reflection of the amazing employees across our district,” Moore said. “When issues arise that require investigation, we take them seriously and cooperate fully with the necessary parties. Our primary focus remains on supporting our students and the incredible educators who serve them.”
Gibbens was transported to the Volusia County Branch Jail and later released on a $2,500 bond.