Volusia County Council approves $13M in ECHO projects

As the council considered the 2026 ECHO grant cycle, including a $2.5M request from MOAS, questions about campaign donations from the Browns led to accusations of 'political theater' on the dais.


Volusia County Councilmen Danny Robins, Matt Reinhart and Chair Jeff Brower. File photo
Volusia County Councilmen Danny Robins, Matt Reinhart and Chair Jeff Brower. File photo
  • Ormond Beach Observer
  • News
  • Share

Improvements to Ormond Beach's softball quad fields, funds for the ongoing redesign of The Brown and an extension of Daytona Beach's boardwalk are among the projects that will receive a total of $13 million of ECHO grants, as approved by the Volusia County Council in a 6-1 vote on Tuesday, Oct. 6. 

The council was given a list of nine projects recommended for funding via ECHO, a voter-approved program that provides dollars for the acquisition, restoration, construction and improvement of projects that fall under environmental, cultural, historical and outdoor recreation criteria. Councilman Don Dempsey was the lone vote against, due to concerns with one of the projects, Conservation Florida's proposed D Ranch Preserve nature center.

A tenth project — Daytona Beach's application for its Harvey Avenue Boardwalk extension and beach access project — was scored below the recommendation threshold by the ECHO Advisory Committee. The project, which will construct about 245 feet of accessible oceanfront boardwalk from Breakers Oceanfront Park south to Harvey Avenue, would match the grant funds using CRA dollars and $8,000 in cash. 

"If you want to move forward in making that area better, this is one step toward it," Councilman Matt Reinhart said. "This is a great use of that resource."

The council was split on this opinion. The project's application passed with a separate 4-3 vote.

Councilmen Jake Johansson, Danny Robins and Troy Kent voted no.

"There's been discussions at Daytona about their use of CRA funds and possible improper use of CRA funds," Johansson said. "Not to say this is an improper use, but given their questionable financial use of monies, it bothers me. I know it's important to the community, but I would like a lot more information." 

Applications

The 2026 ECHO grant cycle will distribute a total of $13,144,290 to six municipalities and four nonprofit organizations.

The projects are:

  • $1,019,290 — Marine Discovery Center, for a new 3,000-square-foot Education Center and 300-square-foot dock providing access to the Indian River Lagoon.
  • $2.5 million — The Brown/Museum of Arts and Sciences, to help make the museum grounds accessible, including a new event lawn, walking paths connecting to the Tuscawilla Preserve and Educational Center, and flexible gathering spaces for outdoor sculpture, water-feature overlooks and outdoor classrooms.
  • $2.5 million — City of Edgewater, for four new boat ramps, ADA-accessible floating docks and gangways, a fishing pier and access to the Intracoastal Waterway and Indian River Lagoon. 
  • $1 million — City of Ormond Beach, for improvements to the city's four softball fields at the Sports Complex, including new clay, Bermuda sod, irrigation, a new pitcher's rubber and bases, shade structtures, fencing and parking lot improvements.
  • $125,000 — City of DeBary, for a new dinosaur-themed splash pad at Community Park. 
  • $2 million — City of Port Orange, for improvements to Willow Run Park, including an expanded playground, accessible bike track, improved courts, pavilions, landscaping and a new restroom.
  • $1 million — City of Holly Hill, for a new pier along the Halifax River at the historic 1868 Ross homestead at Palmetto Point. 
  • $2.5 million — Conservation Florida, for a two-story nature center at its 476-acre D Ranch Preserve. 
  • $100,000 — Volusia Flagler Family YMCA, for a new ADA-accessible playground at the Port Orange Family YMCA.
  • $400,000 — City of Daytona Beach, for an oceanfront boardwalk extending from the existing Breakers Oceanfront Park south toward Harvey Avenue.

According to a county staff report, the 10 projects will leverage $13.2 million in matching funds, for a total community investment of $26.4 million. 

Scoring matrix

This year's ECHO grant applicants were scored with a new matrix. Each applicant, if they met requirements for eligibility, received a minimum 60 points. Board members could assign more points (up to 100) based on the quality of the application, said Community Services Director Brad Burbaugh.

"We don't vote on the quality," he said. "We advise the committee if it met eligibility. So it's a two-part score."

The Daytona Beach boardwalk project scored 77.83, just below the 80-point threshold for eligibility.

For ECHO Advisory Board member Doug Pettit, the new scoring system meant they couldn't freely vote on the quality of the projects and were directed by county staff on how they should vote. 

A map showing the location of all 10 ECHO grant applications. Courtesy of Volusia County
A map showing the location of all 10 ECHO grant applications. Courtesy of Volusia County

"I just don't think it's an honest assessment of what everybody felt about all the projects," Pettit said.

Of the 10 projects, he felt three should be funded — Ormond Beach's softball quad improvement, the Marine Discovery Center's new education center and Edgewater's boat ramps. He had concerns about the rest, from missing or "questionable" feasibility studies, to applications (like The Brown's) exceeding the program's initial $5 million cap on funding. 

MOAS/The Brown has received $4.1 million of ECHO grant funds from 2000-2020. The cap reset in 2020, when the program was extended for another 20 years.

"The ability to be able to look out for these things and express these things, to me, is important," Pettit said. "I hope the taxpayers understand that I'm not trying to be a stick in the mud for projects that might be beneficial, but I'm also trying to make sure that the tax money that they approved — 80% of the population approved this plan — is handled responsibly." 

County Councilman Jake Johansson said at the meeting that there are many projects that didn't meet the eligibility requirements to be scored by the advisory board. 

"It's not that we woke up and said, 'Give everybody a 60, we're moving on,'" he said.


'Political theater'

In regard to voting on ECHO funding for The Brown, County Council Chair Brower asked the county attorney if three council members needed to recuse themselves, as each had received political campaign donations from Cici and Hyatt Brown — major donors, and the namesakes, to the museum's renovation. 

The three council members were Johansson, Danny Robins and David Santiago. Johansson is running for Florida Senate; Robins and Santiago are running for reelection on the council.

County Attorney Mike Dyer confirmed they did not need to recuse themselves, as campaign contributions do not create a conflict of interest for voting purposes, per the Florida Commission on Ethics.

County Councilman Troy Kent, who is not up for reelection, said Brower's statements "crossed a line."

"I feel like you're putting not only the individuals that are running currently, but also Mr. Brown's integrity, into question," he said. "I think it's wildly inappropriate. I don't think it's called for. I feel like the political season is ugly enough, and I just feel like as a body, we are better than that."

Brower responded that the public needs to hear the clarification from the county attorney to clear up any concerns.

"I think it looks ugly to the public who depends on us to handle their money properly," Brower said. "It makes them wonder."

Santiago called Brower's inquiry a "political theater" move.

"He had the answers to that legal question already, because legal already looked at it days ago and told him and told us," Santiago said. "This is the mockery that he makes of this council since he's been here seven — excuse me, six years."

The council chair position, Santiago continued, requires "honor and integrity." The chair shouldn't voice accusations without data to support them, he said.

"He speaks in platitudes like, 'Well, the public should know, or something might be happening' — That's garbage, folks," Santiago said. "Let's talk about the merits of the museum. Tell me why DeBary shouldn't get any money. Tell me why Ormond shouldn't get any money, and why a project is good or not."

Robbins thanked county staff for the clarifications on the program to "combat political peacocking."

"We've done a pretty good job paying attention to the number of support from the public with the ECHO program," County Council member Danny Robins said. " ... I'm not subscribing to this 'doom and gloom' stuff that we've been hearing. It's strictly political, to burn bridges and to create chaos."

 

Latest News

×

Your free article limit has been reached this month.
Subscribe now for unlimited digital access to our award-winning local news.