- November 12, 2026
Dear Editor:
In Grand Landings in Palm Coast, live oak roots have lifted and damaged sidewalks that homeowners must pay to repair.
The HOA says a removed live oak must be replaced with another live oak, even when a certified arborist advises against planting an oak in that location.
Residents who do not comply have reportedly faced fines of up to $1,000, and paying the fine may not end the dispute, as further legal action could still follow.
This forces homeowners to risk recreating the same damage they just paid to fix.
Current law does not protect homeowners in HOA communities from this. Florida Statute 163.045 limits local-government tree rules, but it does not stop a private HOA from enforcing its own replacement rule.
That is why the Florida Legislature needs to change Florida Statute 720.3035, the law on HOA architectural control. This follows Florida's own Florida-Friendly Landscaping principle — Right Plant, Right Place — already in state law FL Statute 373.185.
Rep. Sam Greco's office has responded and requested more information. I have provided it. To show this is a bigger problem affecting many HOA homeowners throughout Florida — not just one case in one community — they need to hear from more than just me.
If you live in an HOA community anywhere in Florida, please contact our state representatives and ask the Florida Legislature to amend 720.3035 to protect homeowners from being forced to replant a tree that has caused documented damage: Sen. Tom Leek, District 7: [email protected]. Rep. Sam Greco, District 19: [email protected].
Ask for a simple fix: an HOA may not require a tree that would recreate documented damage when a qualified professional advises against it, may not fine a homeowner for refusing, and must allow a suitable alternative.
Jeff Baker
Palm Coast